Friday, 9 March 2007

Capital Punishment for Gun and Knife Crimes

The petition is entitled bring back capital punishment for gun and knife crime and the explanatory notes say
"the pain and the heartache of losing a loved one through these crimes is not acceptable"

I would say that the pain and heartbreak of losing a loved one by any crime is not acceptable, and indeed it's fairly unpleasant losing a loved one to anything, crime or not.

I would also say that capital punishment only causes more people to lose their loved ones - gun and knife criminals probably have mothers, fathers, lovers, siblings, etc., too ...

But I suppose one shouldn't be all that sarcastic; at a guess, the petitioner himself has lost someone to something like this. Which being assumed to be so, he's got to be permitted a little irrationality.

That doesn't make it a good idea, however. Two wrongs do not make a right.

No comments: